Dog Harness vs. Collar – Which Dog Walking Gear is Better?

"Should I use a harness or a collar for my dog?" This is one of the most common questions dog owners ask, and for good reason. Choosing the right walking gear can impact your dog’s comfort, health, and behavior.

Whether you’re training a mischievous puppy, walking a spirited senior dog, or managing an energetic breed, the decision between a dog harness and a collar is crucial.

The debate is more than a matter of preference. While collars are a classic choice, harnesses are becoming increasingly popular for their safety and functionality. But which is better for your dog? This guide is here to help. 

We’ll discuss the benefits, drawbacks, and use cases for the best harnesses and collars. You’ll learn to choose the harnesses and collars based on your dog’s unique needs, avoid potential health risks, and even explore insights from experts and trainers.

By the end of this blog, you’ll know:

• When to use a harness versus a collar.
• How these options affect your dog’s health and behavior.
• Practical tips for proper fitting and maintenance to ensure long-term use.

Medical Studies indicate that improperly used collars can exert excessive pressure on the dog’s trachea, contributing to injury and discomfort, especially among small breeds and puppies​. 

Let's avoid making the same mistakes—this blog will arm you with everything you need to walk your dog safely and comfortably.

So. without any further ado, let’s start!!!

Understanding Dog Harnesses and Collars

What Are Dog Collars?

A dog collar is a strap that goes around a dog’s neck and typically serves multiple purposes, including:

• Attaching an identification tag with contact details.
• Connecting a leash for walking.
• Acting as a tool for training or controlling behavior.

• Flat Collars: The standard collar for everyday use.
• Martingale Collars: Ideal for breeds with narrow heads like Greyhounds, offering a snug fit without choking.
• Prong Collars: These collars are used for training but are often controversial due to potential harm.
• Smart Collars: Equipped with GPS tracking and health monitoring features, the demand for smart collars is projected to grow at a CAGR of over 12% between 2024 and 2032, driven by rising adoption of pet tech and safety-conscious owners​. [source]

Well, after understanding the dog collars, let’s learn about the dog harnesses to make informed decisions.

What Are Dog Harnesses?

A dog harness is a piece of equipment that wraps around a dog’s chest, shoulders, and back, redistributing pressure away from the neck. Harnesses are designed to:

• Provide better control, especially for dogs that pull.
• Reduce strain on the neck, making them ideal for dogs with respiratory issues.
• Assist in training by discouraging pulling or jumping.

Types of Dog Harnesses:

• Back-Clip Harnesses: The leash attaches to the back ideal for smaller or less energetic dogs.
• Front-Clip (No-Pull) Harnesses: Helps redirect pulling dogs by attaching the leash to the chest.
• Dual-Clip Harnesses: Combines both front and back attachment points for versatility.

But the question is:

When to Use a Dog Harness Or Dog Collar?

The answer to this question is not one-size-fits-all. Choosing between a dog harness and a collar depends on your dog’s behavior, health, and the activity you’re engaging in. 

Here's a quick breakdown:

• Use a Dog Harness When:

• Your dog pulls excessively during walks, as harnesses provide better control.
• You’re training a puppy or large, strong breeds prone to tugging.
• Your dog has respiratory issues or a sensitive neck.
  
  

• Use a Dog Collar When:

• Your dog is well-trained and doesn’t pull on the leash.
• You need a place for identification tags in addition to a harness.
• You’re taking short, casual walks or supervising your dog indoors.

Fact: Many pet owners find it useful to use both—a harness for outdoor activities and a collar for shorter walks.

Deciding when to use a dog harness versus a collar often depends on your pet’s specific needs and walking behavior. However, understanding unique features and functionality is equally important. 

A closer look at their design, comfort, and control will give you the full picture of how these dog-walking gadgets compare and help you make a choice that aligns with your canine health and lifestyle.

Dog Harnesses vs. Collars: A Comparative Overview

The main difference between Dog Harnesses and Dog Collars is how they distribute pressure and provide control. 

Let’s break down their features to help you decide which suits your furry friend best.

While the features and functions of dog harnesses and collars are essential for day-to-day use, their impact on your dog's health and safety cannot be overstated. 

The right choice of walking gear plays a vital role in your pet's well-being, from preventing neck injuries to ensuring respiratory comfort. 

Let’s explore these critical considerations to ensure your dog stays healthy and happy during every walk.

Health and Safety Considerations for Dog Harnesses and Collars

Preventing Neck Injuries with Harnesses or Collars

Collars are a practical choice for well-trained dogs that don’t pull. When properly fitted, they pose minimal risk and provide a secure spot for ID tags and leashes. For smaller breeds or those prone to neck sensitivity, lightweight and padded dog collars reduce the risk of discomfort or strain.

However, a collar can concentrate pressure on the neck for dogs that pull or lunge. It leads to potential trachea or spinal issues. No-pull harnesses are safer in these cases, as they distribute pressure evenly across the chest and shoulders.

Supporting Respiratory Health

For brachycephalic breeds like Bulldogs and Shih Tzus, or dogs with pre-existing respiratory conditions, collars can exacerbate breathing difficulties by placing pressure on the trachea. In such cases, harnesses are a superior choice, as they bypass the neck area entirely and allow for unrestricted airflow.

But, it doesn’t mean that dog collars are ineffective. Collars remain a good option for short outings or as a backup with a harness. A lightweight collar ensures minimal interference with the dog’s natural movements.

Safety for Active or Large Breeds

Collars can provide sufficient control for large, well-trained dogs during calm activities. Strong, durable collars with secure buckles are ideal for active breeds that may engage in short spurts of energy. However, during vigorous activities or long walks, a harness offers greater control and reduces the risk of injury from sudden lunges.

For the best of both worlds, using a collar for ID and a harness for control ensures your dog stays safe during any activity.

Here, we have listed some of the best dog collars and No-pull dog harnesses to make your task easier.

The Green Pet Shop Bonejour Dog Collar

PetSafe Nylon Martingale Dog Collar

Atopivet Skin Care Collar Dogs Over 22 lbs

Virbac Preventic Tick Collar for Dogs

PetSafe Ultrasonic Dog Bark Control Collar for Dogs

PetSafe Deluxe Easy Walk No Pull Dog Harness, Ocean/Black

The Company of Animals Halti No Pull Harness For Dogs (Large)

PetSafe 3-in-1 Dog Harness with Car Control Strap, Plum

Understanding the health and safety implications of collars and harnesses is only part of the equation. Equally important is how these tools impact your dog’s behavior. 

Whether you’re dealing with pulling, training challenges, or leash obedience, the right gear can significantly influence your dog’s responsiveness and comfort during walks. 

Let’s explore how harnesses and collars shape canine behavior and training outcomes.

Behavioral Insights: Dog Harnesses vs. Dog Collars

How a No-Pull Harness Helps with Pulling Behavior

• Pulling on a leash can turn walks into a frustrating experience for you and your dog. 
• No-pull harnesses are designed with a front-clip attachment point that redirects your dog’s movement when they pull, encouraging them to stay close to you. 
• This setup makes harnesses especially effective for training larger or more energetic breeds.

The Impact of a Dog Collar on Leash Training and Obedience

• For dogs who are already leash-trained, collars can be a simpler and equally effective tool for walks.
• A well-fitted collar provides quick corrections during obedience training without distracting the dog. 
• Additionally, collars allow for greater freedom of movement, which can be beneficial for reinforcing positive leash behavior in smaller or less excitable dogs.
• For training purposes, options like the Herm Sprenger Ultra-Plus Prong Training Collar with Latch are specifically designed to provide better control during walks. 
• The inclusion of a latch mechanism makes it easy to put on and remove while ensuring even pressure distribution, which helps guide your dog effectively.
  

Well, gaining insight into how collars and harnesses affect your dog’s behavior is essential, but knowing how to apply these tools effectively can make all the difference. 

Expert advice can help you choose the right gear for your dog’s training and everyday needs, ensuring you and your furry friend enjoy a harmonious walking experience. 

Let’s explore what professional trainers recommend for getting the most out of your harness or collar.

Expert Tips from Trainers on Choosing a Harness or Collar for Training

• Professional dog trainers often recommend combining both tools to achieve the best results. 
• While harnesses provide control and minimize stress on the neck, collars are great for specific commands and off-leash transitions. 
• Trainers suggest starting with a no-pull harness for initial training phases and transitioning to a collar as your dog becomes more obedient.
• If your dog needs extra protection post-surgery, recovery collars such as the KONG EZ Soft Collar are an excellent choice. This lightweight and flexible collar helps restrict excessive movement while ensuring your pet remains comfortable. 
• For larger dogs, the KONG EZ Clear Collar is a durable alternative that provides similar benefits with added visibility and sturdiness.
• For obedience training and behavioral correction, the Herm Sprenger Ultra-Plus Prong Training Collar is a trusted option. It is particularly effective for dogs that require precise corrections, ensuring safe and controlled training.

Whether you choose a harness, a recovery collar, or a prong collar, selecting the right tool for your dog’s size, breed, and training goals is essential for success.

Now, let’s dive into practical tips for fitting and caring for your dog’s harness or collar.

Proper Fitting and Maintenance Tips for Dog Harnesses and Collars

When it comes to fitting your dog’s gear, precision is key. Here’s how to ensure both collars and harnesses fit perfectly:

For Collars:

• First, measure around your dog’s neck. Then, add two fingers’ width to the measurement to ensure the collar isn’t too tight. 
• A properly fitted collar should rest high on the neck without slipping over the head. 
• This balance prevents discomfort and keeps your dog secure.

For Harnesses:

• Start by measuring your dog’s chest girth and neck circumference. 
• Next, adjust the straps so there’s enough space to slide two fingers between the harness and your dog’s body. 
• This prevents chafing while maintaining a snug fit for better control during walks.

Once you’ve achieved the perfect fit, maintaining the gear is vital to ensure it remains safe and comfortable. Here’s how:

Caring for Your Dog’s Gear

1. Clean Regularly: Wash the gear with mild soap and water After walks, especially in muddy or rainy conditions. This removes dirt, bacteria, and odors, keeping the equipment fresh and hygienic.
2. Inspect Frequently: Check for signs of wear and tear, like frayed edges, rusted hardware, or broken straps. These issues can compromise the safety of your gear.
3. Store Properly: Keep the gear in a cool and dry place to prevent mildew or material degradation.

Pro Tip: Hardy Paw’s Pet Cleaning Supplies includes everything you need to clean your dog’s gear effectively

Recognizing When It’s Time for a Replacement

No matter how well you care for your dog’s gear, it will eventually need to be replaced. Look out for these signs:

• Frayed straps or torn material that compromise the gear’s strength.
• Broken buckles or clips that can no longer secure the harness or collar.
• Visible discomfort, such as redness, fur loss, or irritation under the gear.
• Gear that no longer fits due to growth or weight changes in your dog.

Replacing outdated gear promptly ensures your dog’s safety and keeps their walks enjoyable. 

Which One is Best for My Furry Friend - A Dog Collar or Harness?

The answer depends on your dog’s unique needs, behavior, and lifestyle. Harnesses are ideal for providing control, reducing strain on the neck, and supporting dogs with respiratory or mobility issues. Meanwhile, collars are a lightweight, practical choice for leash-trained dogs, short outings, and everyday identification.

Ultimately, the best option is often a combination of both—a harness for safe, controlled walks and a collar for daily wear and ID. By understanding your dog’s specific requirements and maintaining their gear properly, you can ensure they are comfortable, safe, and happy on every adventure.

FAQs - Dog Harnesses or Dog Collars 

Are Harnesses Better Than Collars for Puppies?

Harnesses are generally better for puppies as they provide more control and reduce strain on the neck. Puppies are often not leash-trained, and harnesses help guide them safely while preventing injuries or choking. Lightweight, adjustable harnesses are ideal for growing pups.

Can My Dog Wear Both a Collar and a Harness at the Same Time?

Yes, using both is a common practice. Collars are ideal for holding ID tags, while harnesses provide control and safety during walks. Ensure both fit comfortably and are not too tight to avoid irritation or restricted movement.

Which is Better for Training a Dog: Collar or Harness?

A harness, especially a no-pull design, is better for training as it offers control without causing discomfort or choking. However, collars can be used for leash-trained dogs during advanced obedience exercises requiring quick corrections.

Can I Leave a Harness on My Dog All Day?

It’s not recommended to leave a harness on all day as it can cause irritation or matting of fur, especially in long-haired breeds. Remove the harness when your dog is indoors or resting to allow their skin to breathe.

What Types of Collars Are Best for Identification Tags?

Flat collars are the best for ID tags as they’re simple, lightweight, and comfortable for everyday wear. Choose a durable collar with a secure buckle to ensure the tags stay in place.

Do Harnesses Prevent Pulling Completely?

No-pull harnesses are designed to reduce pulling by redirecting your dog’s forward motion, but they may not eliminate it. Consistent training alongside the harness can effectively curb pulling behavior over time.

What Materials Are Best for Collars and Harnesses?

Nylon is lightweight, durable, and weather-resistant, making it a great choice for most dogs. Leather offers durability and style but requires regular care. Padded options in either material provide added comfort for extended wear.