Plush Cat Toys

Sort + Filter
Show
Spot 100% Catnip Candy Mice Cat Toy Brown 3.5", 2-pack

Spot 100% Catnip Candy Mice Cat Toy Brown 3.5", 2-pack

Ethical Pet

$5.99
Spot American Take-Out Plush Cat Toy, 2-pack Spot American Take-Out Plush Cat Toy

Spot American Take-Out Plush Cat Toy, 2-pack

Ethical Pet

$4.99
Spot Animal Print Rattle Catnip Toy Assorted, 4.5", 2-pack

Spot Animal Print Rattle Catnip Toy Assorted, 4.5", 2-pack

Ethical Pet

(1)
$4.49
Spot Birds of a Feather Catnip Toy Assorted, 6", 1 Count Spot Birds of a Feather Catnip Toy Assorted

Spot Birds of a Feather Catnip Toy Assorted, 6", 1 Count

Ethical Pet

$4.99
Spot Burlap Mice Catnip Toy Assorted 3", 3-pack Spot Burlap Mice Catnip Toy Assorted 3", 3-pack

Spot Burlap Mice Catnip Toy Assorted 3", 3-pack

Ethical Pet

$4.99
Spot Felt Mice Cat Toy with Catnip Assorted, 6", 6-pack

Spot Felt Mice Cat Toy with Catnip Assorted, 6", 6-pack

Ethical Pet

$6.99
Spot Fun Food Purrgles Kicker Cat Toy, 8", 1-Count

Spot Fun Food Purrgles Kicker Cat Toy, 8", 1-Count

Ethical Pet

$6.99
Spot Kitty Yarn Puffs Catnip Toy Assorted Small 1.5", 4-pack

Spot Kitty Yarn Puffs Catnip Toy Assorted Small 1.5", 4-pack

Ethical Pet

$3.99
Spot Rattle Clatter Mouse Cat Toy with Catnip Assorted, Large 9", 1 Count

Spot Rattle Clatter Mouse Cat Toy with Catnip Assorted, Large 9", 1 Count

Ethical Pet

$4.99
Spot Shaggy Plush Ferret Rattle & Catnip Cat Toy (11") Spot Shaggy Plush Ferret Rattle & Catnip Cat Toy, Black Large 11", 1 Count

Spot Shaggy Plush Ferret Rattle & Catnip Cat Toy (11")

Ethical Pet

$3.99
Spot Stringy Mice & Ball Cat Toy with Catnip, Assorted 2", 4-pack

Spot Stringy Mice & Ball Cat Toy with Catnip, Assorted 2", 4-pack

Ethical Pet

$4.99
Spot Twin Plush Mice Rattle & Catnip Toy, Black & White 4.5", 2-pack Spot Twin Plush Mice Rattle & Catnip Toy, Black & White Twin Pack - 0

Spot Twin Plush Mice Rattle & Catnip Toy, Black & White Twin Pack

Ethical Pet

$2.99
Zippyclaws Halloween Catnip Crusherz Cider & Ale Toy For Cats -2pk Zippyclaws Halloween Catnip Crusherz Cider & Ale Toy For Cats -2pk

Zippyclaws Halloween Catnip Crusherz Cider & Ale Toy For Cats -2pk

ZippyPaws

$6.99
Zippyclaws Halloween Mini Donutz Toy For Cats- 3pk Zippyclaws Halloween Mini Donutz Toy For Cats- 3pk - 0

Zippyclaws Halloween Mini Donutz Toy For Cats- 3pk

ZippyPaws

$8.99
Pearhead Pawloween Toy Set For Cat Pearhead Pawloween Toy Set For Cat

Pearhead Pawloween Toy Set For Cats

Pearhead

$5.99
Fuzzyard Slim Snakey Toy For Cat

Fuzzyard Slim Snakey Toy For Cats

Fuzzyard

$6.99
Snugarooz Day of the Dead Toy For Cats & Dogs Snugarooz Day of the Dead Toy For Cats & Dogs

Snugarooz Day of the Dead Toy For Cats & Dogs

Snugarooz

$6.49
Save
$2
Multipet Lamb Chop Plush Toy with Catnip For Cats Multipet Lamb Chop Plush Toy with Catnip For Cats

Multipet Lamb Chop Plush Toy with Catnip For Cats

MultiPet

$5.99 | $7.99
Kong Kickeroo Crunch Toy for Cats Kong Kickeroo Crunch Toy for Cats

Shop Kong Kickeroo Crunch Cat Toy - Crinkles as Cats Play

KONG

$6.99
KONG Holiday Occasions Catnip Mouse Toy for Cats, 1 count KONG Holiday Occasions Catnip Mouse Toy for Cats

KONG Holiday Occasions Catnip Mouse Toy for Cats

KONG

$6.99
KONG Holiday Crackles Santa Kitty Catnip Cat Toys, 1 count KONG Holiday Crackles Santa Kitty Catnip Cat Toys

KONG Holiday Crackles Santa Kitty Catnip Cat Toy

KONG

$6.89
KONG Holiday Pull-A-Partz Yarnz Toy For Cats (Assorted colors) KONG Holiday Pull-A-Partz Yarnz Toy For Cats (Assorted colors)

KONG Holiday Pull-A-Partz Yarnz Toy For Cats (Assorted colors)

KONG

$6.99
KONG Holiday Pull-A-Partz Present Toy For Cats KONG Holiday Pull-A-Partz Present Toy For Cats

KONG Holiday Pull-A-Partz Present Toy For Cats

KONG

$7.99
Petstages Purr Pillow Kitty Plush Cat Toy, Violet Petstages Purr Pillow Kitty Plush Cat Toy,

Petstages Purr Pillow Kitty Plush Cat Toy, Violet

Petstages

$12.99